Share this photo on Twitter Share this photo on Facebook

The Emptied Container

Posted by
Mariana Maoduš (Waterloo, Canada) on 5 July 2011 in Lifestyle & Culture and Portfolio.

*

Right after the container was emptied, a man is rushing to check out what's there....btw. A man with container works for the Grocery/ Bakery store !
I hope these few words can help to understand this image better ...

Canon EOS REBEL XT 1/500 second F/10.0 ISO 200 75 mm

*

"The moment always dictates in my work. What I feel, I do. This is the most important thing for me. Everybody can look, but they don't necessarily see. I never calculate or consider; I see a situation and I know that it's right, even if I have to go back to get the proper lighting."
~ Andre Kertesz

PATRICK from miramas, France

excellent

5 Jul 2011 5:02am

Z from Shanghai, China

great composition and process. One guy is walking forward and the other is going to right side..

5 Jul 2011 5:13am

jpla from St Barthélémy d, France

Quel joli N&B ! Je et souhaite une agréable journée.
JP

5 Jul 2011 6:47am

Tede from Aubenas 07, France

Splendid processing, a real 3D image. Magnificent job. Marina nice day.

5 Jul 2011 6:55am

Phil from Sausset les Pins, France

Always amazing scene ; I love it ! Phil

5 Jul 2011 7:08am

Willem from Noord-Scharwoude, Netherlands

As always a wonderful processing

5 Jul 2011 7:26am

guillaume from Paris, France

Love your crop and processing !

5 Jul 2011 7:49am

morgan from canyon Country, United States

Great composition and processing.

5 Jul 2011 7:49am

Gérard Beullac from Paris, France

A right angle affair !
Great.

5 Jul 2011 8:05am

abhijit dharmadhikari from Mumbai, India

I liked the theme very much!

5 Jul 2011 8:23am

Chantal from Terheijden, Netherlands

strong with this contrast use

5 Jul 2011 8:23am

Marie LC from Entre montagnes et Bretagne, France

Nice legs ! lol !

5 Jul 2011 8:25am

Mhelene from Paris, France

Great composition and superb effect !

5 Jul 2011 8:53am

vaFA from tehran, Iran

Wow.very good,excellent.nice shot!!

5 Jul 2011 8:54am

Eric C. from Ivry sur Seine, France

Superbe compo and b&w too !

5 Jul 2011 10:44am

Stephen from Canberra, Australia

A most intriguing shot - and excellent tones in b&w. Love the two opposing lines and directions in this shot - with the two figures walking along a different axis.

5 Jul 2011 10:54am

Sam from Chennai, India

Wonderful composition.
One has finished dumping ... Another is rushing to find ...
Ones waste is another's ...
Great concept. Powerful communication ... Love it ... :)

5 Jul 2011 11:32am

klausz from Kufstein, Austria

great angle mariana, and this theme is like ... coming and going .... superb!

5 Jul 2011 11:47am

JCJ from Troyes, France

clean composition and dirty textures, great.

5 Jul 2011 12:05pm

Eric Cousineau from Sherwood Park, Canada

A good street documentary shot Mariana! Life on the streets is a constant struggle! ;-)

5 Jul 2011 12:12pm

Williams from East LaHave, Nova Scotia, Canada

Wow this one moves in every direction all within a compositional box. Excellent!

5 Jul 2011 12:42pm

Michael Skorulski from Canada

A sad life for the vagrant. I like your processing, Mariana.

5 Jul 2011 1:03pm

Michael Skorulski from Toronto, Canada

A sad life indeed.

5 Jul 2011 1:12pm

@Michael Skorulski: I am glad you feel this image, Michael. It was more than sad to me when I spotted this man hiding and monitoring the other man who was going to empty this container. When he felt sure nobody would see him, he almost run to this place and started rumbling through the rubbish !

Melocoton from Salamanca, Spain

I can only tell you that Marian is fantastic, a unique composition and very difficult to empty the center of the image, very complicated
something reserved for the few photographers, *****

5 Jul 2011 1:16pm

Monik from PARIS, France

Une scène de rue comme on en voit hélas de plus en plus... Une image-document excellente!

5 Jul 2011 1:18pm

Phil David Morris 2011 from Saskatoon, Toronto, Canada

What a great composition, so very inventive.

5 Jul 2011 1:21pm

El pare from Prepirineu, Andorra

Original composition.

5 Jul 2011 2:16pm

Blackdog from London, United Kingdom

Another super composition with one chap walking into the frame and the other walking out. Certainly adds to the drama unfolding as explained in your explanation.

5 Jul 2011 2:54pm

Emma.b from France

Great composition ! It looks like a crime scene ...

5 Jul 2011 3:46pm

Rick from Toronto, Canada

Where I work we have "dumpster divers" (what a cruel term that can be) who rummage through the many trash disposal bins that are stored outside the buildings. Most of them climb right inside and are looking for something to eat. This strong image reminds me of those poor hungry people who live desperate lives, and the compo here is amazing for showing the gap between the two men above as they have different realities. The wall makes for a great symbolic "inner frame", and gives me a sense of this man's confined world and way of life. I was feeling all of this as I typed, scrolled back for a second look and saw your reply above... sure would have been funny if I felt and typed all of this and it was completely off-base! Thanks for another great image to make us think.

5 Jul 2011 4:01pm

@Rick: Yes, this is the same story as this image tells us ! Thx for this new slang ( ?) - dumpsters divers ! Did not know it , and now can use for other images with the same theme ;) [ with my apology to those ]

Doug from Burnham-on-Sea, United Kingdom

Nice angle, awful when people have to live that way.

5 Jul 2011 4:04pm

Francisco Romero from Carbajal de la Legua, Spain

A processing that blends with the described situation. Superb composition.

5 Jul 2011 4:48pm

Nicou from Sion, Switzerland

Quel captage, quelle recherche d'image superbe compo quel détail et captage fantastique

5 Jul 2011 5:06pm

mseguid from Es Castell-Menorca-I Balears, Spain

I like the composition and processing.

5 Jul 2011 5:14pm

tataray from france, France

Ohhh.. tu as de ces trucs ... toi !... (rires)
C'est génial.

5 Jul 2011 5:22pm

Christine from Duns, United Kingdom

Fantastic composition and processing and the angle is superb, Rick has expressed things so well I could not say better

5 Jul 2011 6:54pm

Oleg from Podolsk, Russian Federation

Impeccable construction of characters in the picture, although it is clear that this was done almost intuitively. In addition, both characters are active heroes of a little history. Wonderful job!

5 Jul 2011 7:01pm

Denny Jump Photo from Easton, PA, United States

Many would probably be amazed at what is thrown away...one thing for sure, your images are certainly not "throw aways"....!

5 Jul 2011 7:27pm

@Denny Jump Photo: miserable is anyone who comes into situation to search through what was thrown away ....I am not sure if I understood your comment , especially this part of my images ... thx anyway for saying hello !

Elaine Hancock from Rockville, United States

This photo makes a very powerful statement. It is a sad commentary on how some people have to live. Great capture and wonderful processing!

5 Jul 2011 7:57pm

alex centrella from California, United States

well caught, on both sides ...

5 Jul 2011 8:05pm

Denny Jump Photo from Easton, PA, United States

What I meant was that I think your images are always magnificent! They are things that we should keep and not discard because they are so fantastic! ;-)

5 Jul 2011 8:16pm

@Denny Jump Photo: I would never use "not thrown aways " as a synonym of "magnificent", Denny !

Oscar from BCN, Spain

Super! is a HDR in B&W?

5 Jul 2011 8:33pm

@Oscar: once again I really dislike HDR :) or I do not know how to use it properly :)

foto forte from Phoenix, United States

Again, awesome framing, Mariana and very powerful. You know, I had a friend who had a friend that used to do the same thing....dumpster diving. But he did it because he actually hated the waste that stores produced and contended that he could find a lot of things that were still good. I don't think that is the case with your man here, but it is interesting to me that this man appears to be doing this to survive and I know someone who's doing it for completely different reasons. Funny, and sad, too, how the world works. Great job with this one:)

5 Jul 2011 8:35pm

@foto forte: that is really rare situation, Jen . In fact , first time I hear the story like this one . This man I take picture of was very weird to me ... With gloves, with shorts and rainy dirty jacket , and his legs were so dirty, even some dry blood I saw on them ... I was not sure if he was mentally ok ... I moved quickly away; very often I am afraid of these type of people. Thanks Jen !

Kat from Lorraine, France

Original this B&W !

5 Jul 2011 8:35pm

thami from Fès, Morocco

On dirait la promenade dans une cour de prison!
Bonne fin de journée!

5 Jul 2011 8:45pm

Richard from Duns, United Kingdom

Fantastic image!

5 Jul 2011 8:51pm

Gérard Méry from France

Ton traitement rend ta photo encore plus troublante

5 Jul 2011 9:11pm

Frida from Sweden

I would really like to be a fly on your wall to be able to see what you do to "Make" your image style. This is excellent as usual :-)

5 Jul 2011 9:52pm

@Frida: ha ha .. you are sweet ;) no, i do not want you to be a fly , but I would like to take a pretty portrait of you :)

Pascale. from La Bonneville sur Iton, France

sad and strong picture,this feeling being enhanced by the way you have framed. Excellent!

5 Jul 2011 10:01pm

Dokmateo from madird, Spain

Beautiful composition. =)

6 Jul 2011 12:42am

Steve Rice from Olympia, United States

Yes, your words make crystal clear what we are seeing. The man is rushing to be first to see what might be good to eat. A superb shot.

6 Jul 2011 2:38am

Hiro from Kyoto, Japan

I don't want to see the scene with my eyes. Maybe I have to learn this is the real life.

6 Jul 2011 9:45am

foto forte from Phoenix, United States

Just read your response to my post...your sighting of this man sounds a little scary! Be careful!:) Funny, my mom says that to me all the time. If you get a chance to answer this, can I ask where you go to take a lot of your images? I'm sure everywhere but some of the people you photograph seem from a harder side of life, so I am curious. I would love to do that where I live but I find myself quite nervous about it. Anyways, hope you are having a good day:)

7 Jul 2011 7:29pm

@foto forte: My sons are telling me very often - mom , you will get a broken nose one day :) I do not care if I get , nothing can stop me taking pictures of what I like ! Only once I was threatened to get killed by one homeless, who is drunk all the time . He is not interesting to me at all and I do not know why he is yelling at me shouting - put this f... camera down . Almost all my portraits and street images are taken in Waterloo-Kitchener ( 2 little cities connected , without border :))) I love walking and each time I am with camera ! Each time I see something new ! Or some new face , interesting to me . Thanks Jen .

karla from Omaha, United States

The frame shows the divide that I saw before reading your narrative. There is that wiggly line between the two men. One man is employed, looks like he is alive and in good humor. The other....a darkness there that is felt though not quite understood. Amazing image!

7 Jul 2011 11:59pm

Lacroux from Aubergenville, France

Le temps s'arrête, mais les trajectoires ne se rencontrent pas... J'ai appris quelque chose en cherchant sur le web, ce que veut dire BTW ...
Une photo qui pourrait être le début d'un film ou d'un roman...
Bon dimanche.
Pierre.

10 Jul 2011 8:27am

nunush from Isfahan, Iran

perfect!
if you had edited this photo what kind of edit you used for it?

6 Dec 2011 8:23am

@nunush: i edit my picture in 70% cases. Nothing special, just CP2, an old version of Photoshop which I use all the time for all BW pix ! Thanks for visit !

Canon EOS REBEL XT
1/500 second
F/10.0
ISO 200
75 mm